Twelfth Night Cake Recipes

Twelfth Night PartyEnglish Twelfth Night Party with Decorated Epiphany Cake
(PD Source: Issac Cruickshank, May 1794)

Properly celebrate Epiphany by using these authentic Twelfth Night cake recipes to make exquisitely decorated Twelfth cakes, also called King cakes or Epiphany cakes. The festival of Epiphany to celebrate the manifestation of the Christ to the Magi, or wise men, occurs on January 6th, the twelfth day after Christmas Day.

Traditional Twelfth Night Cake Recipes

The Bread and Biscuit Baker's and Sugar-Boiler's Assistant (1890)

Twelfth Night Cake For Celebrating Epiphany FestivitiesTwelfth Night Celebrations

Twelfth Night Cake Recipe

This authentic Twelfth cake recipe was once used commercially by the renowned English confectionery cook, Robert Wells of Scarborough.

1-1/4 lb of flour, 1 lb 2 oz of butter, 1 lb of moist sugar, 4 lb of currants, 1-1/2 lb of mixed peel, 2 nutmegs grated, 1/2 oz ground cinnamon, 10 eggs, 1/2 lb blanched sweet almonds cut in halves, and a wineglassful of brandy.

London Way of mixing Cakes:

Weigh down the flour and sugar on a clean smooth table, make a hole in it, and bank it well up; in this hole put your eggs; cream the butter in an earthenware pan; then add to the flour and sugar the eggs and butter; mix all together and beat up well with both hands. You may work it up this way as light as a feather; then add the currants, spices, etc.

In olden times, a dried bean and a dried pea were introduced into the cake to determine who should be the king and queen of the evening festivities.

Icing Recipe for Twelfth Night Cakes, Bride Cakes, Etc.

To make this take 2 lb of finely powdered icing sugar (first having an earthenware pan made warm), put in six fresh whites of eggs, and immediately whisk them, and as quickly as possible, until quite stiff; then add the sugar by degrees, whisking all the time. As soon as it appears light cease whisking, and beat it well with the spatter until you have put in all the sugar. A little tartaric acid or lemon juice may be added towards the end of the mixing.

To know when it is sufficiently beaten, take up a little on the spatter and let it drop into the basin again. If it keeps its shape it is ready; if it runs it is either beaten too little or requires more sugar.

English Twelfth Night Cake Recipe

Mrs. Goodfellow's Cookery as it Should Be (1865)

Cream two pounds of butter and two pounds of sifted loaf sugar; take one large nutmeg grated, half an ounce of ground allspice, one teaspoonful of ground cinnamon, the same of ginger, the same of coriander seeds, and one wineglass of brandy; mix these well, then beat very light eighteen eggs; cut into thin slices half a pound of citron, and the grated rind of two lemons; beat this for at least half an hour until perfectly light; line the pan with buttered white paper, and bake in rather slow heat for four hours: when nearly cold, ice it.

Parkinson's Twelfth Night Cake Recipe

The Complete Confectioner, Pastry Cook, and Baker (1864)

Rich Twelfth, Pound Cakes, or Bridle Cakes

This old fashioned recipe for what was also called an Epiphany cake is by famed commercial bakery chef Eleanor Parkinson.

Butter two pounds twelve ounces, sugar one pound twelve ounces, currants five pounds, citron one pound and a-half, almonds six ounces; nutmegs, mace, and cinnamon, of equal parts, in powder, two ounces; eggs twenty, brandy half a pint — these proportions allow for the cake being iced.

If more sugar is preferred, the quantity must be the same as the butter; but less is used in this instance, that the cake may be light, and also to allow for the fruit, which would make it too sweet. Double the quantity of almonds may be used if required, as some persons prefer more.

Warm a smooth pan, large enough for the mixture; put in the butter, and reduce it to a fine cream, by working it about the pan with your hand. In summer the pan need not be warmed, as it can be reduced to a cream without; but in the winter keep the mixture as warm as possible, without oiling the butter. Add the sugar and mix it well with the butter, until it becomes white and feels light in the hand.

Break in two or three eggs at a time, and work the mixture well, before any more is added. Continue doing this until they are all used and it becomes light; then add the spirit, currants, peel, spice, and almonds, some or most of these being previously cut in thin slices, the peel having also been cut into small thin strips and bits. When these are incorporated, mix in the flour [enough to make cake batter] lightly; put it in a hoop with paper over the bottom and round the sides, and placed on a baking plate.

Large cakes require three or four pieces of stiff paper round the sides; and if the cake is very large, a pipe or funnel, made either of stiff paper or tin, and well buttered, should be put in the center, and the mixture placed round it; this is to allow the middle of the cake to be well baked, otherwise, the edge would be burnt two or three inches deep before it could be properly done.

Place the tin plates containing the cake on another, the surface of which is covered an inch or two thick with sawdust or fine ashes to protect the bottom. Bake it in an oven at a moderate heat. The time required to bake it will depend on the state of the oven and the size of the cake.

When the cake is cold, proceed to ice it. (See icings for cakes below.) Wedding Cakes have generally, first, a coating on the top of almond icing; when this is dry, the sides and top are covered with royal or white icing. Fix on any gum paste or other ornaments whilst it is wet; and when dry, ornament it with piping, orange blossoms, ribbon, etc.; the surface and sides are often covered with small knobs of white sugar candy whilst the icing is wet.

Twelfth Cakes are iced with white or colored icing, and decorated with gum paste, plaster ornaments, piping paste, rings, knots, and fancy papers, etc., and piped.

Icing for Twelfth Night Cake Recipes

Pound, and sift some treble-refined sugar through a fine sieve, and put it into an earthen pan, which must be quite free from grease; to each pound of sifted sugar add the whites of three eggs, or sufficient to make it into a paste of a moderate consistence, then with a wooden spoon or spatula beat it well, using a little lemon juice occasionally, and more white of egg if you find that it will bear it without making it too thin, until you have a nice light icing, which will hang to the sides of the pan and spoon; or, if it is dropped from the spoon, it should remain on the top without speedily losing the form it assumed.

A pan of icing, when well beat and finished, should contain as much again in bulk as it was at the commencement: use sufficient lemon juice to give the icing a slight acid, or it will scale off the cake in large pieces when it is cut.

About the Twelfth Night Cake Recipes

Dividing the Twelfth Night CakeDividing the Twelfth Night Cake
(PD Source: Anon. circa 1841)

History records that from the Medieval Era to about the mid 1800s, Epiphany or Twelfth Night was celebrated more than Christmas Day in England. It concluded the Twelve Days of Christmas also known as Christmastide, and it was a traditional time for extinguishing the yule log and the partaking of Wassail.

Aside from the enjoyment of food and drink, lively games, costumes, and charades formed an integral part of the festivities. As a climax to the various festivities on January 5th, an ornate Twelfth Night cake was prepared, then ceremoniously sliced and served at the evening feast of Twelfth Night.

Twelfth Night cakes were often very large, richly fruit laden, and sometimes had a classic domed top decorated with two small crowns molded from either colored sugar paste (pastillage) or Plaster of Paris. The cakes were garlanded with ribbons, colorful paper, decorative filagree panels, and sometimes figures fashioned from sugar.

Traditionally symbolic items to be found in the rich, dense fruitcake might be a dried bean (for the king), a dried pea (for the queen), a clove (for the villain), a rag (for the tart), and a twig (for the fool). Whoever found the lucky, baked-in bean and pea was declared King and Queen for the entire evening with the power to lead the revelries and command their betters.

Twelfth night cake recipes were complicated to make and called for expensive ingredients, so those who could afford it often as not purchased them from confectioners' shops. The tradition of Twelfth Night and its elaborate cakes gave way to Victorian Christmas cakes in the 1860s, as the celebration of Christmas Day became more popular in England.

Middle class families celebrated with a less expensive, somewhat plainer cake that was simply iced, if they could afford it.

Today, Christmas fruitcakes, a penny hidden in the plum pudding, and the pulling of Christmas crackers containing tissue paper crowns, novelties, and jokes are reminders of the Twelfth Night tradition.

Thanks to these old fashioned recipes, you can reintroduce this enjoyable, age-old tradition to your holiday gathering. Observe the traditional Twelve Days of Christmas by celebrating Epiphany on January 6th, with a special cake made using these authentic Twelfth Night cake recipes.

Unfortunately, I couldn't locate a public domain image that illustrates what these amazing cakes actually looked like in their traditional form. However, I did manage to come across a website that shows how Twelfth Night Cakes were made, using a historical Twelfth Night cake recipe.

Photos in the article clearly reveal the making of the cake and how the intricately molded sugar paste decorations were created. You'll be impressed with the ornate appearance of the finished cake. Afterwards, return here, and experiment by making one for your Christmas festivities.

The Epiphany of the Magi

Illustration of Madonna and Child

Now when Jesus was born in Bethlehem of Judaea in the days of Herod, the king, behold, there came wise men from the east to Jerusalem, saying, "Where is he that is born King of the Jews? For we have seen his star in the east, and are come to worship him."

And when they were come into the house, they saw the young child with Mary, his mother, and fell down, and worshipped him; and when they had opened their treasures, they presented unto him gifts: gold, frankincense, and myrrh.

—Book of Matthew 2: 1-2, 11

You May Also Like

Easy Christmas Dessert Recipes

Enjoy a Laugh to Brighten Your Day!

Abbott and Costello on Stage

Listen to Bud Abbott and Lou Costello's "Who's On First?" skit from the World War 2 Special Services Division V-Disk.

(5: 54 min.)

Sharing Is Caring Icon

Like This Page? Please Share It

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Visit the Homepage

Old Fashioned Rose and Cookbook Icon
Don Bell with Vintage Recipe Scrapbooks

Click Share and help to preserve Grandma's old fashioned recipes in their original form.

Need Help?

Puzzled about old time oven temperatures and measurement units? Click the Button below for helpful conversions.

Red Help Button

Antique Curiosity

Antique Curiosity

Grandma's button hooks for  fastening tight buttons on leather boots and gloves.