Old Fashioned Donut Recipes

Grandma's old fashioned donut recipes make the best donuts imaginable. So fresh and so crispy! They taste so much better than the store-bought kind when they are homemade. Why not get the family together and make some donuts tonight?

Old Fashioned Donut Recipes

Mom's Recipe Scrapbooks (c. 1920s)

Tray Full of Homemade Donuts Sprinkled with SugarEnjoy Serving Delicious Old Fashioned Donuts
(Source: ©jentara/Depositphotos.com)

Tips for Donut Making

Grandma's Tip

You can always substitute your favorite oil for the lard, but using lard or fat does lend its old time flavor.

Success in making a good fried donut depends as much on the cooking as the mixing. In the first place, there should be boiling lard enough to free them from the bottom of the kettle, so that they swim on the top.

Also, the lard should never be so hot as to smoke or so cool as not to be at the boiling point; if it is, they soak grease and are spoiled.

If it is at the right heat, the donuts will in about ten minutes be of a delicate brown outside and nicely cooked inside.

Try the fat by dropping a bit of the dough in first; if it is right, the fat will boil up when it is dropped in. They should be turned over almost constantly, which causes them to rise and brown evenly.

Wooden skewers come in handy for turning donuts in the hot fat. Some cooks find them handier than tongs for the purpose.

When they are sufficiently cooked, raise them from the hot fat and drain them on a wire rack until every drop ceases dripping.

Mom's Easy Donuts

Old Fashioned-Style Donuts on a PlateTry Mom's Easy to Make Old Fashioned-Style Donuts
(Source: ©tobi/123RF.com)

I know you'll love Mom's Easy Donuts. The good news is these old fashioned-style donuts really are EASY to make!

One of my fondest childhood memories was helping Mom to cut them out and then watch as she fried them in the hot lard.

You will take pride when serving such a crispy, tasty treat to your friends and loved ones, especially when you made it yourself.

1 Egg, 1 cup milk, 1-1/3 cups sugar, 2 teaspoonfuls cream of tartar, 1 teaspoonful baking soda, piece of butter the size of a walnut, 1/4 teaspoonful cinnamon (or nutmeg), pinch of salt, and flour enough to roll soft.

Method:

Beat the egg and sugar together and add the milk and butter. Stir the soda and cream of tartar into the flour, dry; mix all together, with the flour and salt. Roll and cut into doughnut rings, and fry in deep fat. Lay them on brown paper to cool when you take them from the fat.

Eat them plain or sprinkle with granulated sugar if desired. Enjoy them while they are warm and fresh.

Easy Plain Donuts

Turning Donuts with Wooden Skewers During FryingWooden Skewers Help to Turn Donuts When Frying
(Source: ©Shaiith79/Depositdonuts.com)

This old fashioned donut recipe is from a vintage Canadian newspaper clipping found in Mom's scrapbook. Recipes such as this were quite popular in many kitchens in the 1920s.

One egg, one cup of sugar, two tablespoons of butter, beaten together till creamy. Add one cup of sweet milk, a pinch of salt, two teaspoons of baking powder stirred into two cups of flour. Add one-half teaspoon of ginger and one-fourth teaspoon of nutmeg to the flour.

Beat well, roll out about one-fourth of an inch thick. Cut out all the cakes before beginning to fry.

Cook in deep fat that will fry a small walnut-sized ball of the dough in about sixty-five seconds. Do not let the fat get above that degree of heat.

Quick & Simple Donuts

One teaspoonful of soda, two cups of sugar, three spoonfuls cream of tartar, one pint of milk, and flour enough to roll them out in. Fry in hot lard, as also the proceeding. —Mrs. Goodfellow's Cookery

Rhyming Donuts

One cup of sugar, 1 cup of milk;
Two eggs, beaten, as fine as silk;
Salt and Nutmeg, (lemon 'll do);
Baking powder, teaspoons two;
Lightly stir the flour in,
Roll on pie-board — not too thin,
Cut in diamonds, twists or rings,
Drop with care the doughy things,
Into fat that briskly swells,
Evenly the spongy cells,
Fry them brown, just short of burning,
Watch with care the time for turning,
Roll in Sugar, Eat when cool,
Price a quarter for this rule. —Sara E. Zook

Old Fashioned Donut Recipe

Crisco® Shortening, Ladies Home Journal, 1918

Vintage Recipe for Making Barley or Whole Wheat DonutsOld Fashioned Donut Recipe - Ladies Home Journal 1918
(PD Source: Adapted by Don Bell)

These delicious wartime donuts are from World War One. They are described as crisp, light, and sweet. Dry inside with a rich brown crust, delicate and not all greasy.

Note that there's NO sugar and NO lard in this recipe because of the wartime rations. Feel free to substitute whole wheat flour, if preferred, as it was also unavailable during wartime.

Wartime Donuts - Barley or Whole Wheat

To make Wartime Barley Donuts you need:

1 tablespoon melted Crisco® (shortening)
1/4 cupful honey
1/4 cupful corn syrup
1 egg
3/4 cupful buttermilk

3-1/2 cupfuls barley flour (or whole wheat)
1 teaspoon salt
1/2 teaspoon ground nutmeg
3 tablespoons baking powder
1/2 teaspoon soda (baking soda)

1/4 cup chopped nuts

Cream together the melted Crisco®, honey and syrup. Add the egg beaten very light, and the buttermilk mixed with the soda.

Mix the dry ingredients thoroughly and add to the mixture. Lastly, add the chopped nuts.

Roll out on a floured board to one-quarter inch thickness. Cut with a doughnut cutter and fry in Crisco® until a golden brown.

If you use a thermometer, the temperature should be 360°F. Raisins, currents, figs, or dates may be used to vary the recipe.

Old Fashioned Donut Recipes

The White House Cook Book (1913)

Bowls of Old Fashioned Donuts Held by Three Lady ChefsEverybody Loves Old Fashioned Donuts — So Make Lots
(Source: ©everett255/Depositphotos.com)

Just imagine. The recipe for homemade donuts below was once used by the White House kitchen to be eaten and enjoyed by presidents!

German-Style Donuts

One pint of milk, four eggs, one small tablespoonful of melted butter, flavoring, salt to taste; first boil the milk and pour it, while hot, over a pint of flour; beat it very smooth and when it is cool have ready the yolks of the eggs well beaten; add them to the milk and flour, beaten well into it, then add the well-beaten whites; then, lastly, add the salt and as much more flour as will make the whole into a soft dough.

Flour your board, turn your dough upon it, roll it in pieces as thick as your finger and turn them in the form of a ring; cook in plenty of boiling lard. A nice breakfast cake with coffee.

Old Time Puffballs

This old fashioned donut recipe makes a tasty treat similar to what many of us now call Donut Holes. You will enjoy these!

Three eggs, one cupful of sugar, a pint of sweet milk, salt, nutmeg and flour enough to permit the spoon to stand upright in the mixture; add two heaping teaspoonfuls of baking powder to the flour; beat all until very light.

Drop dough by the dessertspoonful into boiling lard. These will not absorb a bit of fat and are not at all rich, and consequently are the least injurious of this kind of cakes.

These puffball-style donuts, eaten fresh and warm, are a delicious breakfast dish and are quickly made.

Old Fashioned Donut Recipe

A New Book of Cookery (1912)

Cheap CRISPY Donuts

This old fashioned doughnut recipe calls for dipping the fried doughnuts quickly into boiling water immediately after they've been fried in oil or lard.

This frying method would likely remove any surface fat making them less greasy and possibly crisper. It's a method also published in Fannie Merritt Farmer's 1912 cookbook.

4 cups flour
1 cup sugar
2 teaspoons cream of tartar
1 teaspoon soda
1 teaspoon salt
1/2 nutmeg, grated
2 eggs
3/4 cup milk

Mix and sift dry ingredients, add eggs, well beaten, and milk, the amount required being about three-fourths cup, sometimes more but never as much as a cup. Toss on a slightly floured board, pat, roll, shape, and fry.

Remove doughnuts from fat, using a two-tined fork, and pass quickly through water kept at the boiling point. The fork must be wiped each time before putting into fat.

Old Fashioned Donut Recipe

Dr. Chase's Third, Last and Complete Receipt Book (1891)

Nutmeg Donuts

Sugar, 1 cup; butter, 1/2 cup; 4 eggs; flour, 3-1/2 cups; milk, 1 cup; cream of tartar, 2 teaspoonfuls; soda, 1 teaspoonful; salt, 1 teaspoonful; nutmeg, to taste.

Directions: Beat sugar and eggs together, with the cream of tartar and butter in the flour; dissolve the soda in the milk, then add it to the eggs and sugar, then the flour; roll out thin, cut and fry in hot lard.

Old Fashioned Donut Recipe with Jam

Cookery (1895)

Jam Filled Raspberry Donuts

There's something especially appealing about this old fashioned Canadian donut recipe.

Just reading about these jam-filled-treats makes your mouth water. Any flavor of jam would be delicious in them.

Take the same mixture as for plain doughnuts, roll it out rather thinly and stamp into rounds, put a little raspberry jam on half the rounds, brush the edges with water and cover with the remainder, press them firmly together and fry in hot fat five minutes. Sprinkle with sugar.

Old Time Fruity Fried Donuts

Fruity Fried Donut TreatYou'll Love These Fruity Fried Donut Treats
(Source: ©marek_usz/Depositphotos.com)

Fruity Donuts

Here's an idea for a donut-style treat. Use your favorite old fashioned donut recipe, but instead of cutting donut shapes, take bits of the dough and wrap them around pieces of fruit. Apple slices and berries are totally delicious inside a fruity fried donut!

Related Pages You Might Like


Like This Page? Please Share It

Get Grandma's old fashioned donut recipes and make your own donuts and pastry treats. Pin for later!