Traditional Halloween Recipes

Merry Halloween Vintage Greeting CardA Merry Halloween Greeting Card
(Source: Public Domain)

These traditional Halloween recipes will help to brighten your family's celebration. Below you'll find old fashioned recipes for Halloween candy, cakes, candy apples, scary treats, and more. Make some delicious treats to serve at your next Halloween party.

Traditional Halloween Recipes

The Halloween treats below are delicious, affordable, and very easy to prepare. Plus, the vintage Halloween party ideas are a whole lot of fun. There's nothing like celebrating an old fashioned Halloween!

The Celebration of Halloween

Homemade Halloween Monkey Costume 1955Halloween Monkey Costume (1955)
(Source: ©Don Bell)

In Canada and the United States, costumed kids carrying treat bags rush from house-to-house in the early evening on October 31st shouting "Trick or Treat" while hoping the householders will be generous in offering candy and other goodies.

If treats are not offered, some kids have been known to play TRICKS on the stingy householders, such as soaping their windows or winding toilette paper around their shrubs before ringing the doorbell and then running away.

That's me pictured above in my homemade Halloween costume. Handsome, eh? Mom sewed the monkey suit for me on her Singer treadle sewing machine, and I won the prize for best costume at the old one-room school I attended in 1955. Boy was I thrilled! Those school parties were so much fun.

Halloween candy is the still the big attraction, but much of the candy handed out today is store-bought for safety's sake. Sadly, it's a different world.

Back in the 1950s, treats were mostly homemade using traditional Halloween recipes, though some gave store-bought Chiclets gum and tiny chocolate bars.

We enjoyed taffy apples, popcorn balls, chocolate fudge, and peanuts in the shell. And who could forget those yucky brown Halloween candies in their orange and black wrappers? They were set aside and eaten last.

Nothing beats an old fashioned Halloween!

History of Halloween

© by Don Bell

1905 Halloween Party at the Archibald Gentles Ranch in Alberta1905 Halloween Party at Archie Gentles Ranch, Alberta
(Source: Don Bell)

The celebration of Halloween is thought to have originated from an ancient Celtic religious festival that signified the start of the darker season of winter on November 1st, and the end of their calendar year.

A new holiday was established by the Christian church in the 800s, and October 31st became celebrated as All Hallows or All Saints' Day, when the poor went from house to house begging treats called "soul cakes" made by the Christians.

The word "Hallow" means "one who is holy." October 31, the evening before All Saints' Day, became known as All Hallows' Eve, or All Hallow e'en, resulting in today's Halloween.

Early settlers to North America brought their popular beliefs and customs with them, and Halloween was considered a fun celebration for adults. It wasn't until the early 1900s that it became closer identified with children and treats. One of the earliest references to "trick-or-treat" appeared in a Canadian newspaper published in 1911.

In the old photo above, my Grannie Bell (nee Gentles) can be seen in the second row, second from the left, a year before her marriage to my grandfather. The 1905 Halloween party was typical of celebrations on the Alberta Prairie. Note the absence of costumes, though they did enjoy lively music thanks to two Scottish pipers and their bagpipes.

The old Halloween traditions formed the basis for our modern celebrations, and the traditional Halloween recipes, costume disguises, candlelit jack-o'-lanterns, candy treats, apples, and silly acts of mischief gradually became part of the fun.

Through the years, some so-called "tricks" were not so harmless, or fun. My father recalled outhouses being moved back a few feet so the unsuspecting householder would fall into the waiting pit. Imagine!

Sometimes party guests went to return home and found their buggy hitched to the horse, the buggy on one side of the fence and the horse on the other. It was even said that one neighbor who wasn't well liked awoke the following morning surprised to find his hay wagon sitting fully assembled on the peak of his barn roof!

Making Fun Halloween Treats

Little Girl Eating a Red Candy AppleEnjoy a Candy Apple
(Source: ©iStock/101cats)

When it comes time for Halloween, you can turn almost any dessert into a colorful and delicious Halloween treat.

For example, the use of orange food coloring (or a combination of yellow and red colors) can add a festive color to many ordinary foods.

Also, there are any number of candies that can be used as dessert toppings and decorations for Halloween, such as candy corn, orange and black jellybeans, and black licorice shapes.

Learning how to make BOO-tiful Halloween treats is not difficult, especially with Grandma's traditional Halloween recipes. You'll love the wholesome taste.

Plus, there's tons of old fashioned recipes to be found elsewhere on this site that can be adapted for Halloween. Just use your imagination.

If you care to serve something truly unique to adults, you won't find anything to compare with the old fashioned Irish Barmbrack Recipe for making an authentic "soul cake" that's to be eaten at Halloween.

The traditional Halloween recipes and party ideas on this site (Top) will help to get you started. Kids of all ages will enjoy making the old fashioned Halloween candy, desserts and party treats.

Sharing Is Caring Icon

Like This Page? Please Share It

Visit the Dessert Homepage

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Old Fashioned Cookbook and Rose