Tips for Making Perfect Cupcakes

Follow Grandma's tips for making perfect cupcakes and learn how to make old fashioned cupcakes as she made them. The first and most important step is the baking process, and it's all explained below.

While absolute perfection isn't necessary, the tips and instructions as given will help you to get as close as possible. Grandma's methods will help ensure that your homemade cupcakes are the right size, moist in texture, delicious tasting, and beautiful looking.

Grandma's Tips for Making Perfect Cupcakes Anytime

How to Make Homemade CupcakesLearn How to Make Perfect Cupcakes Like Grandma's
(Source: DIYplr)

Always Preheat Your Oven

Always take the time to preheat your oven and ensure that you set it at the precise temperature called for in the recipe.

Allow about 10 to 15 minutes to make certain your oven has reached the proper temperature before inserting your cupcake tins.

How to Choose Cupcake Liners

Cupcake Decorated with Chocolate Icing and SprinklesTips for Making Perfect Cupcakes Like Grandma's
(Source: ©nito103/

Following Grandma's tips for making perfect cupcakes is one thing, but you must also know how to make your cupcakes look presentable! That's where quality liners play a big part. Not only do they add to the cupcake's appearance, but they make it easier to eat.

However, not all cupcake liners are the same quality. As Grandma used to say, you get what you pay for. The cheapest paper liners got stuck on the baked cupcakes, making them difficult to peel off without taking little pieces of the cupcake with them. Nobody likes that.

Thin paper liners can also appear greasy after baking which can detract from your cupcake's appearance. So, if you plan to serve your cupcakes in their liners, choose a liner that's suitable. Consider paying a little extra for better quality!

Cupcake Liner Choices

  • Quality paper liners for cupcakes are thicker, and some feature a nonstick coating on the inside. They work very well, and they feel pleasingly soft and natural in your hand. They are also quite decorative, coming in various colors and designs.
  • Parchment paper liners also work well, as the parchment won't stick to the cupcakes, and it's recyclable. However, parchment paper can sometimes appear greasy after baking, and it has a plainer appearance.
  • Tulip baking cup liners are popular for baking cupcakes and muffins, and since they are higher than the cupcake top, they're available in a variety of colors to suit any occasion. The grease-proof paper releases easily from the cupcake and offers an extra wide surface to catch the crumbs while eating.
  • Foil cupcake liners can add elegance to any cupcake at a cost just slightly above the paper variety. They come in an assortment of colors and designs to suit any occasion. However, be aware that foil liners are not the greenest of choices since they cannot be composted.
  • Reusable silicon cupcake liners offer a good alternative to paper and foil liners. Most are sturdy enough to be set on a cookie sheet for baking, and they are reusable and dishwasher safe. They come in a variety of bright colors and have a nonstick surface, though some users recommend spraying them with cooking oil for an easier release.
  • Edible cupcake liners offer a clever solution to those who don't care for liners. Imagine the fun of eating both the cupcake and its liner! An edible liner bakes onto the cupcake, taking on its taste, and its texture. Manufacturers include Bake Huggers™, and Dr. Oetker®. Edible liners are new and not yet widely available, so keep watching for them in stores.

Cupcake Liner Sizes

Finally, make sure you use the right size liners for your baking tin. Most "standard" (2-1/2 inch) cupcake tins can hold "standard" liners, up to the larger size liners.

However, if you try to use a liner that's too large for your pan, it will distort the shape of your cupcake.

If you want "extra large" or "jumbo" cupcakes, you will need what's called a Jumbo (3-1/2 inch) cupcake tin with its larger openings for 6 cupcakes, and Jumbo size liners that fit these larger pans perfectly.

Tips for Making Perfect Cupcakes Without Liners

There might be times when you run out of liners or times when you would prefer not to use them.

To bake cupcakes WITHOUT liners, always make sure to grease and flour your muffin tin. Simply brush butter on with a pastry brush. Then add a little bit of flour to each cup and shake and tap the tin, so each cup is fully coated.

Finally, shake off any extra flour into your waste bin, and you're ready to add the batter and pop them in the oven.

Follow Your Cupcake Recipe

Mix Cupcake BatterMixing Your Cupcake Batter
(Source: DIYplr)

If the cupcakes are for a special occasion and you need them to be perfect, either make a practice batch first or use the delicious cupcake recipes you are familiar with.

When it's a recipe you've used before you can always be sure of the results. Following Grandma's tips for making perfect cupcakes and having them turn out perfect every time does require a little practice when it's an unfamiliar recipe.

Read the cupcake recipe in full before starting and always pre-measure your ingredients and gather the bowls and pans you'll need. A few minutes spent in preparation will help ensure you don't make any mistakes.

Add the Right Amount of Batter

Filling Cupcake LinersFill Your Cupcake Liners 2/3 Full
(Source: DIYplr)

It's always a temptation to add more batter than necessary when you're learning how to make homemade cupcakes from scratch. However, follow these tips for making perfect cupcakes:

Only fill your cupcake liners 2/3 to 3/4 full. DO NOT over fill, or your cupcakes will overflow their liners while baking, resulting in a real mess. A glass measuring cup with a pouring spout works well to measure out thin batter.

Some cooks prefer an ice cream scoop for adding the correct amount of batter to each cupcake liner. Use a medium scoop that measures about 3 tablespoons when filling standard liners.

For Jumbo cupcake liners, one heaping ice cream scoop should be enough.

Always Watch Your Baking Time

Toothpic Cupcake TestUse a Toothpic to Test When Cupcakes Are Done
(Source: DIYplr)

Of all Grandma's tips for making perfect cupcakes, this is maybe the most important tip to remember when learning how to make cupcakes the old fashioned way.

As soon as your cupcakes go in the oven, set your timer! Always set it to the recipe's "minimum" recommended baking time and even then, watch them carefully, and test for doneness.

Here's how to tell when your cupcakes are perfectly baked and ready to remove from the oven:

  1. Insert a toothpick into the center of your largest cupcake (if any are visibly larger). If the toothpick comes out clean without any batter or crumbs attached, it's done.
  2. Gently press your finger on the center of a cupcake. If it jiggles or doesn't spring back instantly, you need to allow more baking time.

Careful testing will ensure perfect cupcakes every time!

Cool Your Baked Cupcakes

When your baked cupcakes test ready (see above), remove the tin from the oven and allow your cupcakes to sit for a few moments until cool enough to handle.

Don't leave your hot cupcakes sitting in their tin for long, though, as moisture buildup can cause the liners to pull away from the cupcakes.

Gently remove the individual cupcakes from the tin and place them on a cooling rack for about 30 minutes.

Cupcakes should be completely cool before you ice them or your icing will melt and not hold its shape. Once they've cooled, decorate them as you wish, or store them for decorating later.

How to Store Your Cupcakes

If you plan on decorating your cooled cupcakes later, cover them loosely with wax paper, so their tops remain dry. They will become sticky and harder to decorate if you cover them tightly or place them in a sealed container.

Follow the above tips for making perfect cupcakes, and you'll find that learning how to make your own cupcakes is easy and rewarding when you follow your recipe and complete the needed steps in order.

Make Cake Batter Cupcakes

Aside from the featured homemade cupcake recipes from scratch, did you know that you can make tasty cupcakes from almost any cake batter?

Most of the basic chocolate cake and white cake recipes on this site will make great tasting cupcakes.

However, your cake batter cupcakes should be baked in a slightly hotter oven than you would use for baking cakes, because of their small size, and be sure to watch your baking times.

You Might Like These

Check This Out

Join Grandma's Dessert Club Today and…

Grandma McIlmoyles Little Dessert Book

Download your FREE COPY of Grandma McIlmoyle's Little Dessert Book. Also receive regular Club Bulletins with delicious recipe suggestions straight to your inbox, and more.

My special Gift to you!

"Love your Grandma's Dessert Club Bulletins! I look forward to each issue." —Sharon, USA

Like This Page? Please Share It