Old Fashioned Sweet Potato Pie Recipe

Grandma's favorite old fashioned sweet potato pie recipes are surprisingly easy to make, and the baked pies are delicious with an authentic Old South flavor. I guarantee you will want seconds, so you better bake two!

Simply choose whatever style of homemade pie appeals to you. Some enjoy their sweet potato pies with a flaky top crust, others prefer the melt-in-your-mouth meringue version, while still others prefer an old-style open pie.

So, it's your choice. All pies are delicious! Enjoy a tasty dessert pie from that hails from the Old South.

Old Fashioned Sweet Potato Pie Recipe

Dishes & Beverages of the Old South (1913)

Southern Sweet Potato PieEnjoy a Delicious Southern Sweet Potato Pie
(Source: ©bhofack2/Depositphotos.com)

Old South Sweet Potato Custard Pie

Grandma's Secret

Never leave a sweet potato pie in the oven until it looks totally done. The center of the pie should always jiggle a bit, so the pie will finish baking as it cools and turn out perfect.

Boil tender two large or four medium sweet potatoes, peel, free of strings, and mash fine. Add to the pulp half a pound of creamed butter, mix well, then add gradually five cups sugar, alternately with five whole eggs. Beat smooth.

Add the juice of three lemons, a tablespoonful lemon essence, and a scant pint of very rich milk. Use less milk if the potatoes are very soft. Beat smooth and pour into pie pans lined with good crust. Bake brown in a fairly quick oven (try 350°F), but do not over bake.

Lest the proportion of sugar may seem excessive, let it be said here that sweet potatoes require more sugar for sweetening in pies than anything save crabapples or green gooseberries.

Covered Sweet Potato Pie

Line a deep pie pan with short crust rolled a quarter-inch thick, fill it with raw sweet potatoes, peeled and sliced thin.

Add to them, for a pan of medium size, three cups sugar, a cup of butter, cut in bits, mace, cloves and nutmeg to taste, half a cup of cold water and half a cup good whiskey or sherry.

Cover with a crust an eighth-inch thick, prick well, also cut a tiny cross in the middle, and bake in a hot, but not scorching oven (375°F), three-quarters of an hour — maybe a full hour if the pan is large.

Turning another pan, fitting the rim over, helps to make the baking sure and even. Remove the cover pan ten minutes before taking up. Serve hot. This pie requires no sauce.

Old Fashioned Sweet Potato Pie Recipe

The White House Cook Book (1913)

Southern Open Top Sweet Potato Pie

One pound of steamed sweet potatoes finely mashed, two cups sugar, one cup cream, one-half cup butter, three well-beaten eggs. Flavor with lemon or nutmeg and bake in pastry shell. Fine.

Old Fashioned Sweet Potato Pie Recipe

Second Edition of the Neighborhood Cook Book (1914)

Old South Sweet Potato Meringue Pie

Boil or bake sufficient sweet potatoes to make a pint of the pulp when rubbed through a colander. Add one pint of milk, small cup sugar, pinch of salt, yolks of two eggs, one teaspoon vanilla extract. Bake 350°F in shallow pan lined with rich pie crust.

When done beat the whites of the eggs with two tablespoons powdered sugar. Spread over top of the pie. Brown slightly in the oven.

Old Fashioned Sweet Potato Pie Recipe

Submitted by Anon.

Elvis's Favorite Pie

Making a Sweet Potato PieMaking an Old Fashioned Sweet Potato Pie
(Source: ©kmlPhoto/Depositphotos.com)

This recipe is said to closely reproduce the sweet potato pie that Elvis Presley loved to eat at Graceland.

2 large sweet potatoes
1-1/2 cups sugar
3 eggs
1 tablespoon vanilla extract
1 tablespoon nutmeg powder
1/2 cup butter
1/2 cup whole milk
1 9-inch unbaked pie shell

Bake sweet potatoes until tender, then cool, and peel, and mash. Combine potatoes with other ingredients. Pour pie mixture into pie shell. Bake in preheated 350°F oven for 50 minutes, or until done. Enjoy.

Sweet Potato Table Decoration

Sweet Potato Table DecorationSweet Potato Table Decoration
(Source: ©luciana-bueno-santos/123RF)

When you gather sweet potatoes for an old fashioned sweet potato pie recipe, set one aside to make a living table decoration, and a topic of conversation.

"Table decoration is my hobby," says a writer in the Christian Science Monitor. "I have tried all kinds of roots and seeds in a dish of stones and water and find that some are very much prettier than others.

"One of the most attractive centerpieces is a growing horseradish root. Split the roots so the rootlets can run out in a low dish, filled with small stones and water.

"No care is required except to maintain fresh water covering only about half the roots and the picking of wilted leaves. These roots will last three or four months before decay.

"Carrot tops make an artistic fernery. I have mixed carrots and horseradish roots, making a fancy table decoration.

"Not long ago, I placed two small sweet potatoes in a plain, deep pottery dish and behold! In a few weeks, I had a beautiful, trailing vine that was admired by all who looked at the glossy green leaves." — Christian Science Monitor c.1920

You Might Like These

Check This Out

Join Grandma's Dessert Club Today and…

Grandma McIlmoyles Little Dessert Book

Download your FREE COPY of Grandma McIlmoyle's Little Dessert Book. Also receive regular club Bulletins with delicious recipes straight to your inbox, and more.

My special Gift to you!

"Love your Grandma's Dessert Club Bulletins! I look forward to each issue." —Sharon, USA

Like This Page? Please Share It