Eggnog Shake Recipes

Adding an Egg to the ShakerAdding an Egg to the Shaker to Make an Eggnog Shake
(Source: ©Serreitor/Depositphotos.com)

Have fun trying these eggnog shake recipes to make what were once called Egg Shakes by the old time soda jerks. They are similar to an eggnog yet uniquely different, some call for milk while others contain sparkling soda water. These thick shakes are not only delicious, but spark great conversation.

Old Time Eggnog Shake Recipes

The Dispenser's Formulary or Soda Water Guide (1915)

Drug Store Soda FountainEverybody Wanted an Egg Shake at the Drug Store Soda Fountain
(Source: ©everett255/Depositphotos.com)

Whenever the soda jerk had added an egg to a milkshake before shaking, it became a delicious Egg Shake. Acid syrup flavors should NEVER be used in making eggnog shake recipes, as the acid tends to curdle the milk or cream.

Eggnog shake recipes call for raw, uncooked eggs. To avoid any health risk, please read my Raw Eggs and Salmonella article for simple instructions on how to safely use raw eggs.

Genuine Egg Milkshake

1 ounce any desired flavor of syrup, 1/4 glassful finely shaved ice, enough milk to make 12 ounces, 1 egg. Shake and strain. This formula makes a genuine egg milk shake. Use very little ice. Charge 15 cents.

Sportsman's Shake

One fresh egg, 1 dash strawberry syrup, 1 teaspoonful sugar. Place in a glass in the order named and fill with milk; shake well and strain in glass. Top off with grated nutmeg. Charge 15 cents.

Egg Vichy

One egg, 1/2 glass shaved ice, 1 ounce pure water. Shake thoroughly; then add slowly, while constantly stirring enough Vichy water (or soda water) to fill the glass. Price—12 ounces, 10 cents.

Chocolate Egg Shake

2 ounces chocolate syrup, 1 scoop cracked ice, 1 egg, enough milk to nearly fill glass. Pour the syrup into the glass, add the egg, and cracked ice, then fill the shaker about one-third full of milk and shake.

Finally, add the balance of the milk to fill the shaker about two-thirds full. Shake well and strain into a clean glass. Top off with a little powdered mace, nutmeg, or cinnamon.

The above formula is recommended for making a chocolate egg shake. Price—12 ounces, 15 cents.

Egg Chocolate

1 ounce chocolate syrup, white and yolk of 1 egg, small quantity of crushed ice. Shake well, then add plain carbonated water sufficient to fill tumbler.

Stir with twist bar spoon, strain, then pour alternatively from tumbler to shaker, and serve. This drink is rather thin and should not be priced at more than 10 cents.

Conger's Egg Chocolate

1 ounce chocolate syrup, 1/2 ounce vanilla syrup, 1 egg, piece if ice size of walnut. Shake well together, add plain soda and pour from shaker to glass three times; top off with nutmeg. Price 12 ounces—10 cents.

Hawaiian Chocolate Shake

This eggnog shake recipe calls for vanilla ice cream and tastes similar to a chocolate ice cream soda.

Break and separate an egg; beat up the white with half an ounce of chocolate syrup, and the yolk with a similar quantity of pineapple crushed fruit syrup; beat the two mixtures well together and then shake up with an ounce of chocolate syrup and a scoopful of vanilla ice cream.

Pour into a 12-ounce glass and fill with carbonated water, fine stream. Serve with two straws. This formula may be much improved by dispensing all milk instead of carbonated water and charging 20 cents for 12 ounces. —Beverly F. Towne

American Gentleman

Juice of 1 orange, 3 teaspoons powdered sugar, 1 egg, 1 ounce grape juice, 1/4 ounce port wine, small quantity shaved ice. Add ingredients to glass, fill glass with plain water; shake, put in 12-ounce lemonade glass, finish with a slice of pineapple and a cherry.

The "American Gentleman" may be livened up by the application of a little carbonated water. Price—12 ounces, 20 cents.

Big Gun Egg Shake

Juice of 1 lemon, 1 egg, 1 tablespoonful powdered sugar, 2 ounces shaved ice. Shake thoroughly, strain into a 12-ounce glass, and fill with ginger ale. The Big Gun Egg is a good thirst quencher. Charge 15 cents.

Cupid's Delight

This eggnog shake recipe calls for vanilla ice cream and pineapple ice making it a veritable ice cream sundae in a glass.

Use a lemonade shaker. Put in a scoopful of soft vanilla ice cream, 2 teaspoonfuls pulverized sugar, one scoopful of pineapple ice, and one egg; beat the mixture well with a spoon and pour on a fine stream of carbonated water to make a 12-ounce drink; top off with whipped cream and serve with two straws.

No syrup is required in this drink. Price—12 ounces, 10 cents. —Howard E. Rollison

Strawberry Egg

To 1 egg in mixing glass, add 2 ounces of strawberry syrup, 2 ounces of plain cream, shake well with ice, and serve in bell glass filled with carbonated water. Charge 10 cents.

Charlotte Shake

To small quantity of shaved ice in a tumbler, add 1 whole egg, a little sweet cream, and maraschino syrup (syrup from a jar of maraschino cherries may be used); shake the whole well and fill the glass with milk. Price—12 ounces, 15 cents.

Olympic Egg Shake

A small quantity of shaved ice, juice of 1 lemon, 1 ounce grape juice, 1 egg, 2 tablespoonfuls powdered sugar. Dispense in a 12-ounce lemonade glass, fill with carbonated water, and garnish with an orange slice and a cherry. Charge 15 cents.

Lunar Blend

This eggnog shake recipe makes a drink that's similar to an old time float beverage.

Take two mixing glasses, break an egg, putting the yolk in one glass, the white into the other; into the glass with the yolk add one ounce cherry syrup and some cracked ice, shake, add small quantity carbonated water and strain into a 12-ounce glass.

Into the other mixing glass add one ounce plain sweet cream and beat with a bar spoon until well whipped, add one-half ounce lemon syrup, then transfer it into shaker and add carbonated water and float mixture on top of the yolk and cherry syrup. Serve with two straws.

Washington Egg Shake

2 ounces grape juice, juice of half a lemon, 2 teaspoonfuls powdered sugar, 1 egg, 2 ounces plain water, cracked ice. Shake together well. Prepare a large goblet in the following manner:

In bottom of glass put pieces of ice, one tablespoonful of pineapple sherbet. Over this pour a ladleful of grated pineapple, then strain the contents of shaker over all, garnish with fruit and serve with a spoon and straws. Charge 20 cents.

Kansas High Ball

Juice of 1 lemon, 3 ounces grape juice, 1 egg, simple syrup to sweeten, half a scoop of cracked ice, water.

Mix in a glass, shake well, jerk up with carbonated water, strain and serve in 8- or 10-ounce stem glass. Price, 15 cents. —Vance R. Thralls

Navy Egg Shake

This eggnog shake recipe makes a refreshing spicy shake that leaves a tingle on the tongue.

Into a 14-ounce glass pour 2 to 2-1/2 ounces of strawberry syrup. Into this break two eggs and add a few dashes of Jamaica ginger, 1 to 2 ounces of sweet cream, and a little fine-shaved ice.

Shake thoroughly and fill with carbonated water. Strain into clean glass and serve. May be topped with spice, if desired.

The carbonated water should be added to the syrup and eggs in the shaker and from the shaker strained into the serving glass. Price—12-ounce glass, 20 cents.

Carbonated Water (soda water) can be found for sale in the soft drink section of most food and convenience stores.

Torani Soda Syrups can be found for sale at Amazon in dozens of flavors ranging from Classic Root Beer to Watermelon.

Related Pages You May Like


Sharing Is Caring Icon

Like This Page? Please Share It


Old Fashioned Cookbook and Rose