How to Make Homemade Pies

Learn how to make homemade pies the old fashioned way. It's an art that's easily mastered, especially when you have the same tips that Grandma used for making pie and pastry.

Mom made pies every week when I was a boy. And I have yet to find any baked goods that can surpass the fragrant, sweet aroma of a freshly baked pie as it sits cooling at an open window.

Sometimes a pie never got a chance to cool before it began to disappear!

Strawberry Pie with a Lattice Top Ready for the OvenOven Ready Strawberry Pie with Lattice Crust
(Source: ©elenademyanko/

The practical baking tips below reveal how to make homemade pies. They can be applied to any of the old fashioned pie recipes on this site.

You can make a delicious homemade pie from scratch that's perfect for any occasion. Why not bake one tonight? Make your Grandma proud!

How to Make Homemade Pies In Six Basic Steps

The White House Cook Book (1913)

Cutting Pie CrustCutting the Pie Crust Evenly Around the Edge
(PD Source circa 1919)

Step 1

After making the crust, take a portion of it, roll it out and fit it to a buttered pie plate by cutting it off with a knife evenly around the edge.

Step 2

Gather up the scraps left from cutting and make into another sheet for the top crust. Roll it a little thinner than the under crust.

Lap one-half top crust sheet over the other and cut three or four slits about a quarter of an inch from the folded edge (this prevents the steam from escaping through the rim of the pie, and causing the juices to run out from the edges).

Step 3

To prevent the juice soaking through into the crust, making it soggy, wet the pie's under crust with the white of an egg, just before you put in the pie mixture.

Step 4

Now fill your pie plate with your prepared filling, wet the top edge of the rim, lay the upper crust across the center of the pie, turn back the half that is lapped over, seal the two edges together by slightly pressing down with your thumb, then notch evenly and regularly with a fork, dipping occasionally in flour to prevent sticking.

Step 5

Bake pie in a rather quick oven (425°F) to a light brown, and until the filling boils up through the slits in the upper crust.

Step 6

If the top of the pie is brushed over with the egg, it gives it a beautiful glaze.

How to Make Homemade Pies

The White House Cook Book (1913)

Showing How to Make Pies from ScratchShowing How to Make Homemade Pies from Scratch
(Source: White House Cook Book 1913)

A former White House chef shares her proven old fashioned pie making tips:

  • Use the best materials in making pastry; the shortening should be fresh, sweet, and hard; the water cold (ice water is best), the paste rolled on a cold board and all handled as little as possible.
  • When the crust is made, it makes it more flaky and puff more to put it in a dish covered with a cloth and set in a very cold place for half an hour, or even an hour.
  • A great improvement is made in pie crust by the addition of about a heaping teaspoonful of baking powder to a quart of flour, also brushing the paste as often as rolled out, and the pieces of butter placed thereon, with the white of an egg, assists it to rise in leaves or flakes. As this is the great beauty of puff paste, it is as well to try this method.
  • If currants are to be used in pie making, they should be carefully picked over and washed in several waters, dried in a towel and dredged with flour before they are suitable for use.
  • Raisins, and all dried fruits for pies and cakes, should be seeded, stoned and dredged with flour before using.
  • Almonds should be blanched by pouring boiling water upon them and then slipping the skin off with the fingers. In pounding them, always add a little rose-water or orange-water, with fine sugar, to prevent their becoming oily.
  • Great care is requisite in heating an oven for baking pastry. If you can hold your hand in the heated oven while you count twenty, the oven has just the proper temperature and it should be kept at this temperature as long as the pastry is in; this heat will bake to a light brown and will give the pastry a fresh and flaky appearance. If you allow the heat to abate, the under crust will become heavy and clammy and the upper crust will fall in.
  • Another good way to ascertain when the oven is heated to the proper degree for puff paste: put a small piece of the paste in before baking the whole, and then the heat can thus be judged of.
  • Pie crust can be kept a week, and the last are better than the first, if put in a tightly covered dish and kept cold, and thus you can make a fresh pie every day with little trouble.
  • In baking custard, pumpkin, or squash pies, it is well, in order that the mixture may not be absorbed by the paste, to first partly bake the paste before adding it, and when stewed fruit is used, the filling should be perfectly cool when put in, or it will make the bottom crust sodden.

With practice in following the above tips, you will gain confidence in knowing how to make homemade pies that you'll be proud to serve.

You Might Like These

Check This Out

Join Grandma's Dessert Club Today and…

Grandma McIlmoyles Little Dessert Book

Download your FREE COPY of Grandma McIlmoyle's Little Dessert Book. Also receive regular club Bulletins with delicious recipes straight to your inbox, and more.

My special Gift to you!

"Love your Grandma's Dessert Club Bulletins! I look forward to each issue." —Sharon, USA

Like This Page? Please Share It