Grandma's old fashioned lemon meringue pie recipes make the best-tasting homemade pies imaginable. Why? Because these tangy lemon pies are topped with a fluffy baked meringue that's so good it simply melts in your mouth.
I really love eating these old time dessert pies, and you will too. But, I now have a problem: I no longer want to eat a slice of lemon pie that isn't homemade!
Store-bought pies can't match the exceptional taste of these amazing fruit pies crowned with their fluffy homemade meringue. I dare you to bake one and see how good it really tastes!
Mom's Recipe Scrapbooks (1920s)
Rebecca, a valued visitor to this site, has suggested that after adding the 3 cups boiling water and bringing it to a boil in the following old fashioned lemon meringue pie recipe, you should allow the lemon mixture to become sufficiently thickened before removing it from the stove and putting it in baked crusts.
Juice of 2 lemons, 2 cups sugar, yolks of 3 eggs, 4 tablespoons flour, piece of butter. Stir all together with a little cold water. Add 3 cups boiling water and bring to a boil. (See Rebecca's Tip.)
Remove from stove and put in baked crusts. This will make 2 pies. Then, beat the whites of the 3 eggs to a stiff froth. Add sugar and spread meringue on top of pies.
Lemon Pie Filling:
1/2 cup sifted cake flour, 1-1/4 cups sugar, 1 cup boiling water, 1 to 3 cups milk, 3 egg yolks beaten with 1 egg white, 1/2 tablespoon butter, 2 lemons (1/4 cup juice), grated rind 1 lemon, 1 baked 9-inch pie shell.
Combine flour and sugar in top of double boiler. Add boiling water, stirring constantly; then add milk. Cook until thickened, stirring constantly.
Pour small amount of mixture over beaten egg yolks and egg white, stirring vigorously. Add egg mixture to double boiler, and continue cooking until mixture drops in thick sheets from spoon. Add butter, lemon juice, and rind. Cool and pour into baked pie shell.
4 tablespoons sugar, 1/4 teaspoon salt, 2 egg whites stiffly beaten. Fold sugar and salt in beaten egg whites. Pile lightly on filling. Bake in slow oven (300°F) 12 minutes, or until meringue is a delicate brown.
Aunt Babette's Cook Book (1889)
Line a deep pie plate with a rich puff paste, and bake a light brown. Remove from the oven until the filling is prepared.
Take a large juicy lemon, grate the peel, and squeeze out every drop of juice. Now take the lemon skin and put it into a cup of boiling water to extract every particle of juice.
Put the cup of water on to boil with the lemon juice and grated peel, and a cup of sugar; beat up the yolks of four eggs very light and add to this gradually the boiling lemon juice. Return to the kettle and boil.
Then wet a teaspoonful of cornstarch with a very little cold water, and add also a teaspoonful of butter and when the boiling mixture has thickened remove from the fire and let it cool.
Beat up the whites of the eggs to a very stiff froth, add half of the froth to the lemon mixture and reserve the other half for the top of the pie. Now bake the lemon cream in the baked pie crust (at 350°F until slightly jiggly in the center).
For the meringue, add a few tablespoonfuls of powdered sugar and half a teaspoonful cream of tartar to the remaining beaten whites. If you desire to have the meringue "extra thick," add the whites of one or more eggs.
When the pie is baked, take it from the oven just long enough to spread the meringue over the top, and set back for two or three minutes, leaving the oven door open just the least bit, so as not to have it brown too quickly.
The White House Cook Book (1913)
The historical Ebbitt House hotel and first-story restaurant as it appeared around the time the old fashioned Superior Deep Dish Lemon Pie was on its menu.
The entire Hotel building was demolished in 1926, and the National Press Club Building was afterwards erected at the same location. Thankfully, the Ebbitt House's homemade lemon meringue pie recipe remains for us to enjoy.
Take a deep pie dish, grate into it the outside of the rind of two lemons; add to that a cup and a half of white sugar, two heaping tablespoonfuls of unsifted flour, or one of cornstarch.
Stir it well together, then add the yolks of three well-beaten eggs, beat this thoroughly, then add the juice of the lemons, two cups of water and a piece of butter the size of a walnut.
Set this on the fire in another dish containing boiling water and cook it until it thickens, and will dip up on the spoon like cold honey.
Remove it from the fire, and when cooled, pour it into a deep pie tin, lined with pastry; bake at 350°F, and when done (with a slightly under done center), have ready the whites, beaten stiff, with three small tablespoonfuls of sugar.
Spread this meringue over the top and return to the oven to set and brown slightly. This makes a deep, large-sized pie, and very superior. —Ebbitt House, Washington, D.C.
If you don't have enough lemons for making an old fashioned lemon meringue pie recipe, try making this delicious orange pie instead.
It makes a pleasant change from lemon when topped with a fluffy meringue, and it's an easy pie to make.
Grate the rind of one and use the juice of two large oranges. Stir together a large cupful of sugar and a heaping tablespoonful of flour; add to this the well-beaten yolks of three eggs, two tablespoonfuls of melted butter. Reserve the whites for frosting.
Turn this into a pie pan lined with pie paste and bake in a quick oven (375°F). When done so as to resemble a finely baked custard, spread on the top of it the beaten whites, which must be sweetened with two tablespoonfuls of sugar; spread evenly and return to the oven and brown slightly.
The addition of the juice of half a lemon improves it, if convenient to have it.
Submitted by Kathleen, USA
Here's my favorite old fashioned Lemon Meringue Pie Recipe that's easy to make and oh so tasty! I have been making this for about 40 years, since I was 10 years old or so, and now it's a family favorite. —Kathleen, USA
First, let's make the easy lemon pie:
3 eggs yolks
1 can (14-ounce) of Sweetened Condensed Milk
1/2 cup of lemon juice
You will also need 1 regular sized Graham cracker pie crust, homemade or any brand. Note: If the crust is large, you may have to double the recipe.
Pour 3 egg yolks into a large bowl and just mix them to break them a little. Add 14 ounces of Sweetened Condensed Milk and mix well. Add lemon juice and mix on medium high to high to mix in juice well (pie will be runny if not well mixed).
Pour mixture into pie shell and bake about 30 minutes a preheated oven set at 325°F.
Next, prepare the meringue topping:
3 egg whites
1/ teaspoon cream of tartar (optional)
3/4 cup of sugar
Clean your utensils and mixer very well making sure there isn't a hint of egg yolk in sight. It will stop the egg whites from frothing if there is!
In clean DRY bowl, pour the 3 egg whites into a larger bowl and whip on high for a few minutes until really frothing. You can add 1/2 a teaspoon of cream of tartar, but it's not really necessary.
When they are really frothing, start adding 3/4 cup sugar SLOWLY while you keep whipping on high. Keep adding and you'll notice that the egg whites are beginning to thicken and stiffen.
Keep whipping until you have stiff peaks that don't fall when you scoop them up and put them back in the bowl again.
(Sometimes I buy a small carton of egg whites and add more to the 3 called for in the homemade lemon meringue pie recipe, but remember, you will then have to use more sugar to stiffen the whites too.)
When you reach this point, start spooning the whipped egg whites on the top of the freshly baked pie being sure to spread them somewhat evenly and be sure to seal the edges to the pie crust.
You can get a little creative with them too by making waves, curls, adding sugar sprinkles to show a little color, make faces, or whatever you want!
When done with the egg whites, put the pie into a preheated oven now set at 350°F for 15 minutes, or until golden brown. Set baked pie on cooling rack, allow to cool, then refrigerate for at least 2 hours before serving.
P.S.: It's NOT a good idea to make this old fashioned lemon meringue pie recipe on a very hot and humid day!
The extra moisture in the air can impede the egg whites from forming the froth, or getting stiff enough to hold that special curl! However, in today's home air conditioning, or on a cool or non humid day, it's fine!
Serve and Enjoy! I mean ENJOY!