Want a homemade cookie icing recipe that you'll use again and again? Decorating icing is so easy and quick to make, and the icing flows on and hardens just right every time. You'll love it. There's nothing like a homemade sugar cookie with icing to tempt your sweet tooth. Not only does the icing add flavor and richness to the cookie, but it adds a tantalizing appeal.
Mom's Recipe Scrapbooks (c. 1920s)
A tray of colorfully frosted cookies can turn any dessert table into a work of art. Decorate your cookies and watch the delight in the eyes of your friends and loved ones.
Bring to boil equal amounts of granulated sugar and water. Stir occasionally until sugar is completely dissolved. For thicker glazed, reduce by cooking and stirring occasionally until you reach consistency desired. Remove from heat and allow syrup to cool to room temperature. Brush over cookies or cake, or drizzle using a spoon or measuring cup. Great for either cookies or cakes.
1 cup confectioner's sugar
3 teaspoons milk
2 teaspoons corn syrup
1/4 teaspoon vanilla flavoring (almond or maple flavorings are also good)
Stir sugar and milk together in a bowl until icing mixture is smooth; beat in corn syrup and vanilla until icing mixture is smooth and glossy in appearance. Add food coloring to desired shade. Ice cookie and set aside for the icing to harden to a nice glaze.
Egg whites, 2
Butter, 1 cup
Icing sugar, 4 cups
Whip ingredients together until thick enough to spread. For chocolate frosting, add 1 cup cocoa. For colored frosting, add food coloring as needed.
Submitted by A. Miriam
This original cookie icing recipe was invented by Miriam, a regular visitor to this website. She accidentally discovered a great way to make cookie decorating icing using ice cream. That's right, ICE CREAM.
I'll let her tell you all about it:
"I accidently found a great frosting recipe for decorating cookies. It is so simple and hardens quickly so that you can stack the cookies. I had run out of milk one day while decorating cookies. So, I melted some vanilla ice cream and added powdered sugar — and it was perfect!
"The ice cream is already full of delicious ingredients. One can just add food coloring or leave it white; then add sprinkles, if desired. You have to add the sprinkles quickly before the frosting hardens, though." —Miriam, USA
Our heartfelt thanks to Miriam. Isn't she clever? Vanilla ice cream works great with powdered icing sugar for making decorating frosting, but you can also experiment by using plain chocolate or strawberry ice cream to add a subtle flavor and tint to the frosting.