Tasty Old Fashioned Cookie Recipes

Grandma's old fashioned cookie recipes make the best cookies from scratch you've ever tasted. These homemade cookies are wonderfully inexpensive to make, and their ingredients are so wholesome that you and your children can eat them freely.

You will love seeing everyone enjoying your old time cookies. Heck, they'll rave about them! And they might even steal them! (Read more about that below.) But, don't worry, you can always make a fresh batch in a pinch.

Grandma's Old Fashioned Cookie Recipes

Assorted Homemade CookiesAssortment of Grandma's Homemade Cookies
(Source: ©Dukell/Depositphotos.com)

Everyone loves a rich treat, and these homemade chocolate cookie recipes deliver that old fashioned chocolatey goodness in every bite.

These naturally delicious coconut cookies are a tropical delight that Grandma used to bake right in her own kitchen.

For making a delicious buttery treat that melts in your mouth, you can't beat these classic shortbread cookie recipes from Grandma's collection.

Discover the nostalgic taste of easy-to-make peanut butter cookies that feature that traditional fork-crisscross pattern we all remember.

Hearty and wholesome, these old fashioned oatmeal cookies are the perfect snack for tucking into a school lunchbox or snacking on.

You'll love the chewy texture of these vintage oatmeal raisin cookies that have always been a family favorite.

These tasty almond cookie recipes make cookies with a delicate nut flavor that pairs perfectly with a warm cup of tea.

Mom's honey date-filled pinwheel cookies are as attractive and festive to look at as they are delicious to eat.

Enjoy the rich, nutty crunch of Mom's favorite butter pecan cookies made with real butter and fresh pecans.

Learn the secret to making traditional homemade ladyfingers that are light, airy, and perfect for your favorite desserts.

Grandma's spicy, fruit-filled old fashioned hermit cookies are a classic treat that only gets better with age.

When you're in a hurry, these quick and easy drop cookie recipes are the perfect way to fill the cookie jar.

Brighten your day with these tangy lemon cookie recipes that offer a refreshing burst of citrus flavor.

Grandma's old fashioned molasses cookies are soft, chewy, and filled with the warm spices of yesteryear.

These classic macaroon cookie recipes are sweet, chewy, and surprisingly simple to bake from scratch.

Spend a fun-filled afternoon in the kitchen with your children making Grandma's cut out cookie recipes. Easy and so delicious!

Save time with these old fashioned icebox cookie recipes that allow you to slice and bake whenever the craving strikes.

These vintage refrigerator cookie recipes are perfect for keeping dough on hand for unexpected guests.

Grandma McIlmoyle's raisin filled sugar cookie recipe features a sweet fruit center hidden inside a soft, golden cookie.

These melt-in-your-mouth meringue cookies are light as a cloud and make for a truly elegant treat to serve your guests.

Tune in to the past with these vintage radio cookie recipes that were once shared over the airwaves.

Every baker needs this collection of versatile sugar cookie recipes to bake perfect treats for any occasion.

Fill your kitchen with the tantalizing aroma of Grandma's old fashioned ginger cookies and spicy gingersnaps.

These fun gingerbread men recipes are an irresistible holiday tradition that children of all ages will love to eat anytime.

Rediscover these forgotten cookie recipes that were once treasured staples in every old fashioned pantry.

When you need something extra special to impress your guests, Grandma's fancy cookie recipes are sure to please.

You can't go wrong with Mom's old fashioned chocolate chip cookies filled with plenty of melting chocolate.

Finish your treats beautifully with these vintage recipes for cookie icing and decorative frostings.

Cookie Cutters, Sheets, Jars

Get practical tips on using cookie cutters and even learn how to make your own custom shapes.

Find out where to get collectible old fashioned cookie jars to keep your homemade treats fresh and on display.

Choosing the best baking and cookie sheets is the secret to getting perfect, even results every time you bake.

Step away from the oven and enjoy some good old fashioned fun activities and nostalgic stories.

Also look in the TOP MENU under the International and Holiday categories for more old fashioned cake recipes.

Thanks for the Memories

Bob HopeBob Hope Performs at USO Show Overseas c. 1960s
(PD Source: U.S. Army Photo)

Bob Hope wasn't the only one who had fond memories. I can recall when growing up on the farm, there was always a large tin of freshly baked cookies sitting in the pantry.

I was told not to touch them, but I often sneaked one or two when Mom wasn't looking — okay, okay — I confess. I sneaked a handful.

Sometimes I got caught, but Mom never complained too much. She loved to see us enjoying them, and she could always bake more when needed.

Tucked away in the happy carefree memories of childhood, everybody has a special cookie jar or tin. Maybe it sat in one corner of the cupboard, or maybe it was set high up to keep little hands from removing its contents too easily.

Sometimes the jar was filled with sugar cookies, sometimes with hermits, and at other times with crisp, golden ginger snaps. Whatever cookies it held, its contents were always a household joy to children — of all ages.

Homemade Sugar CookiesWhy Not Make Some Homemade Cookies Today?
(Source: ©rakratchada/Depositphotos.com)

Now, thanks to Grandma's old fashioned cookie recipes, your children will have their own fond memories. You'll find recipes for a wide variety of homemade cookies above. They're so much fun to make that you'll want to try them all.

When it comes to homemade cookies, you can never have too many on hand for unexpected guests, and they also make a wonderful gift for someone special, whatever the occasion.

Make Cookie Sandwiches

Homemade Cookie Sandwiches Served on a Cake StandMake Mouth-Watering Cookie Sandwiches
(Source: ©laperlafoto/123RF.com)

Here's a great idea for a dessert treat. Make Cookie Sandwiches simply by spreading icing between two homemade cookies made from any of Grandma's recipes.

A Brief History of Cookies

Vintage Housewife Making Cookies

Cookies, small and round, sweet and delicious, have been a beloved treat for centuries. However, have you ever wondered where they came from? The answer to that question is a journey through time and culture.

The story of cookies most likely begins in Persia during the seventh century. At that time, sugar cane was being utilized in Persia, and it's thought that small cakes or biscuits were being baked there. These early cookies were likely simple by today's standards but still provided a sweet treat.

As sugar became more widely available throughout Europe during the Elizabethan Era, recipes for homemade cookies became popular. People would gather to bake these sweet treats in large quantities as a way to celebrate holidays or special events.

The word "cookie" is said to come from the Dutch word koekje which means "little cake." However, in the UK and some Commonwealth countries like Australia and Canada many still call them biscuits. In Germany, they are called keks or kels while Italy has two popular cookies known as amaretti and biscotti.

Despite their name differences across cultures, one thing remains consistent: cookies always taste best when made at home with love! And what better way to make them than with Grandma's old fashioned cookie recipes.

Homemade cookie recipes are not just about making something sweet but also about preserving tradition. Every recipe tells its own story; some have been passed down through generations while others were created by someone who wanted to make something new and special for their loved ones.

For example, take chocolate chip cookies. We all know them as an American classic but did you know they were invented in the late 1930s by chef Ruth Wakefield who wanted something different to serve with ice cream. The result of her recipe was extraordinary! A delicious cookie filled with melting chocolate chips in every bite.

Another famous cookie is the snickerdoodle. This cinnamon and sugar coated delight was brought to America by German and Dutch immigrants in the late 1800s. The name "snickerdoodle" may come from the German word Schneckennudel, which means "snail" or "crinkly noodle." But, no matter what you call them, these cookies are a crowd-pleaser at any gathering.

From oatmeal raisin to peanut butter, homemade cookies come in all shapes and sizes and have become an integral part of our lives. Whether it's for a special occasion or just an afternoon snack, there's nothing like enjoying a warm homemade cookie with a glass of milk.

So, cookies have come a long way from their humble beginnings in Persia to becoming one of the most beloved treats worldwide. They have been shaped by different cultures and traditions over time but their appeal remains universal: sweet, deliciousness that brings joy to our taste buds!

Grandma McIlmoyles Little Dessert Book

Sign Up now for GRANDMA'S DESSERT CLUB and download your FREE PDF COPY of Grandma McIlmoyle's Little Dessert Book. Also receive my regular Bulletin featuring classic recipes and nostalgia.


Learn More

don-bell-archivist

Don Bell, Founder & Archivist, Old Fashioned Dessert Recipes. Don has spent over two decades preserving heritage dessert recipes from handwritten family notebooks, vintage cookbooks, and recipe scrapbooks. His collection spans hundreds of authentic, old fashioned recipes presented exactly as originally written.


Like This Page? Please Share It

Get Grandma's Homemade Cookie Recipes. Pin for later!