Unique Thanksgiving Recipes

Lima Bean Custard DessertLima Bean Custard Dessert

Here are some unique Thanksgiving recipes for making harvest-style desserts to delight your guests and earn you well-deserved praise. Everyone will love the taste of these old fashioned desserts that are so in keeping with the autumn season.

Just imagine a delicious lima bean custard, an onion souffle, a tomato and corn pudding, a recipe for fritters made with beets, and more. You will want to try these Thanksgiving desserts. They are totally delicious and are always a topic of conversation.


Mom's Unique Thanksgiving Recipes

Mom's Recipe Scrapbooks (c. 1920s)

Lima Bean Custard

Wash one cupful of dried lima beans, cover them with cold water and soak overnight. Drain and put them into a saucepan covered with cold water, and boil until they are soft. Rub them through a sieve, add half a pint of sugar, two teaspoonfuls of butter, three beaten eggs, half a cupful of milk, and one teaspoonful of vanilla extract.

Mix and divide into custard cups, cover with buttered papers, and steam gently for half an hour. Serve hot or cold with sweet wafer cookies.

Onion Soufflé

Vintage Onion Souffle RecipeOnion Souffle with Sugar

Melt two tablespoonfuls of butter in a saucepan, add three large, sliced onions and one cupful of water, cover tightly and let the onions steam until tender and all the water is cooked out, then allow them to become a yellowish color.

Remove from the fire, mash the onions, add one tablespoonful of flour, the yolks of three eggs and three tablespoonfuls of sugar beaten together, one tablespoonful of butter, two tablespoonfuls of cream, a quarter of a teaspoonful of salt and the whites of the eggs stiffly beaten.

Divide into small, buttered baking dishes suitable for serving in, sprinkle a little sugar and chopped nuts over the top, and bake until ready.

Beet Fritters

Vintage Beet Fritters RecipeBeet Fritters with Ice Cream

Two beets, the yolks of four eggs, three tablespoonfuls of flour, three tablespoonfuls of cream, one tablespoonful of sugar, a grate of nutmeg, and the rind of half a lemon. Boil the beets until tender, then skin them and rub them through a sieve, add the yolks well beaten, the sugar, cream, flour, nutmeg, and lemon rind.

Mix well and form into neat fritters, using a little flour. Allow to stand for fifteen minutes in a cool place, then fry in smoking-hot fat or lard. Serve decorated with fresh or preserved apricots, or homemade ice cream.

Squash and Walnut Croquettes

Vintage Squash And Walnut Croquettes RecipeSquash and Walnut Croquettes

Rub two cupfuls of cooked squash into a basin, add one egg well beaten, two tablespoonfuls of melted butter, one tablespoonful of sugar, a quarter of a teaspoonful of salt, four tablespoonfuls of flour, and half a cupful of chopped English walnut meats.

Form into neat croquettes, brush over with a beaten egg, toss in fine bread crumbs, and fry in plenty of smoking-hot fat or lard.

Drain, and serve the croquettes with a sweet dessert sauce. This unique Thanksgiving recipe makes a delicious dessert that you can serve on any occasion.

Tomato and Corn Pudding

Vintage Tomato And Corn Pudding RecipeTomato and Corn Pudding

One cupful of cooked corn, one cupful of sliced or quartered raw tomatoes, four tablespoonfuls of butter, four tablespoonfuls of bread crumbs, one teaspoonful of sugar, and seasoning of salt and pepper to taste. Mix and pour into a buttered baking dish. Sprinkle a few bread crumbs over the top, dot with small pieces of butter, and bake for half an hour in a moderate oven. Serve hot in the dish in which the pudding was baked.

Lentil Cakes

First wash one cupful of lentils in several waters and soak them in water for twelve hours; then boil them until soft but not pulped. Drain and add two tablespoonfuls of melted butter, one tablespoonful of sugar, a quarter of a teaspoonful of salt, yolks of two eggs, and half a cupful of chopped nutmeats.

Make into small round cakes, lay on buttered tins, and bake in a hot oven for fifteen minutes. Sprinkle a few chopped nuts on top and serve hot.

Breadcrumb Tartlets with Currants

Line gem or muffin pans with pastry. Put one cupful of milk and two tablespoonfuls of butter into a saucepan, bring to boiling point, and carefully pour over a quarter of a pound of white breadcrumbs; add three tablespoonfuls of sugar, one tablespoonful of lemon juice, three tablespoonfuls of currants, and two beaten eggs. Lightly mix. Put a spoonful of this mixture into each gem pan and bake until done.


You May Also Like

If you love the unique Thanksgiving recipes above, then you'll definitely want to see Grandma's old fashioned Thanksgiving Baking Recipes and try the old time squash muffins, potato scones, and pumpkin brown bread with vegetable marrow jam. So amazingly delicious!

Squash MuffinsSquash Muffins

Easy Thanksgiving Dessert Recipes





Like This Page? Want to Share It?



Facebook Comments

Have your say! Leave a friendly comment about Grandma's old fashioned desserts in the box below. (No links or promotion please.)






Visit Home Page

Don Bell With Old Fashioned Recipes

Please click the Like button above and help me preserve Grandma's old fashioned recipes in their original form.


Need Help?

Puzzled about old time oven temperatures and measurement units? Click the Button below for helpful conversions.

Help Button Icon

Recent Articles

  1. Fun with Hand Shadows

    How to make hand shadows of animals, birds, people, and more. Enjoy an old fashioned pastime that's fun for any age.

    Read More

  2. Old Fashioned Homemade Pancake Recipes

    Grandma's homemade pancake recipes will make delicious old fashioned pancakes you'll love to eat and serve anytime.

    Read More

  3. Richard Wilts 1st Aeolian Harp

    I saw a picture of an Aeolian Harp in an old 1956 handyman book and decided to make one. I tried to find 1/8 thick wood that was at least 7 wide but couldn't

    Read More

  4. Homemade Christmas Pudding Recipes

    Grandma's favorite Christmas pudding recipes for making traditional plum puddings for your Christmas dinner.

    Read More

  5. Homemade Cheesecake Recipes from Mom's old Recipe Box

    These homemade cheesecake recipes are so easy to make, and the cheesecakes are full of old fashioned flavor and goodness.

    Read More


Craftsy Free Cake Decorating Classes
Disclosure: I am an affiliate of Craftsy. If you purchase a product through one of their links, or any affiliate link, I may receive a small commission that helps to support this site so I can continue bringing you Grandma's recipes. Thank you.