Old Time Peach Pie Recipes

Baking Peach Pie From ScratchBaking Peach PIes from Scratch
(Source: Adapted from Cow Brand Baking Soda booklet, c.1923)

You'll love these vintage peach pie recipes. They are true nineteenth-century classics. Just imagine the flavorful taste of sweet, juicy peaches encased in a rich, flaky pie crust. You will savor each forkful. In fact, you'll want seconds!

And remember, nothing goes better with a slice of warm-from-the-oven pie made with peaches than a big scoop of homemade vanilla ice cream. These two treats were made for each other — peaches and cream. Make an old-fashioned pie today.

Aunt Babette's Peach Pie Recipes

Aunt Babette's Cook Book (1889)

No-Bake Peach Cream Pie

Line a pie plate with a rich crust and bake, then fill with a layer of sweetened grated peaches which have had a few pounded peach kernels added to them. Then whip one cupful of rich cream, sweeten and flavor, and spread over the peaches. Set in ice-chest until wanted.

Peach Meringue Pie

Line a pie plate with a rich pie crust, cover thickly with peaches that have been pared and sliced fine (canned peaches may be used when others are not to be had), adding sugar, and cover with strips of dough and bake quickly.

If you do not mind the expense, spread over the peaches a meringue made by whipping the whites of three eggs to a stiff froth and sweetening with a tablespoonful of pulverized sugar for each egg. Add half a teaspoonful cream of tartar to the meringue; flavor with vanilla and set back in the oven until the meringue begins to color. Take out carefully. Eat cold. Delicious served with cream.

Peach Meringue Pie

Pare, stone and slice the peaches. Line a deep pie plate with a rich paste, sprinkle a very little cornstarch over the bottom crust and lay in your fruit, sprinkling sugar liberally over them in proportion to their sweetness. Add a few peach kernels, pounded fine, to each pie, and bake with crossbars of paste across the top.

If you want it extra fine, whip the whites of three eggs to a stiff froth and sweeten with about four teaspoonfuls of pulverized sugar, adding a teaspoonful cream of tartar and spread over the pie and return to the oven until the meringue is set. Eat cold.

Easy Deep Dish Peach Pie Recipe

The Dominion Home Cook-Book (1868)

The Dominion of Canada was only a year old when this traditional peach pie recipe was first published.

Take mellow juicy peaches, wash and put them in a deep pie plate, lined with pie crust. Sprinkle a thick layer of sugar on each layer of peaches, put in almost a tablespoonful of water and sprinkle a little flour over the top, cover it with a thick crust and bake the pie from fifty to sixty minutes.

Party Peach Pie Recipe

Party Peach PieEnjoy Party Peach Pie for Your Next Get-together
(PD Source: Mary Lee Taylor Recipes)

Mary Lee Taylor Recipes (c.1940)

Evaporated Milk

One cup half and half or 1 cup light whipping cream can be substituted, but for the closest flavor to evaporated milk, gently simmer 2-1/4 cups whole milk in a saucepan until reduced to 1 cup.

Wonderful flavor — no baking at all!

One can Cling Peach Slices in syrup is needed for the recipe.

1. Mix 2 tablespoons melted butter, 1/2 cup graham cracker crumbs.

2. Save 2 tablespoons crumb mixture for 6-inch pie. Press rest of crumbs firmly in bottom and on sides of pie pan. Chill.

3. Mix 2 tablespoons sugar, 4 teaspoons cornstarch, pinch of salt.

4. Stir in slowly until smooth 1/3 cup peach syrup from can, 1/3 cup PET Evaporated Milk.

5. Add 1 teaspoon butter.

6. Stir over boiling water until thick and smooth. Then cook 10 minutes, stirring now and then.

7. Remove from heat and stir in 1 slightly beaten egg yolk.

8. Cook and stir over boiling water until mixture thickens, or about 3 minutes. Cover and cool.

9. When custard is cold, add 1/3 teaspoon vanilla flavor.

10 Pour half of custard into crumb-lined pan.

11. Arrange on custard half of canned cling peach slices, well drained.

12. Cover peaches with rest of custard. Arrange rest of peaches on top. Put rest of crumbs in center, between peach slices. Chill 3 hours or longer.

Apple and Peach Meringue Pie Recipe

The White House Cook Book (1913)

Stew the apples or peaches and sweeten to taste. Mash smooth and season with nutmeg. Fill the crusts and bake until just done. Put on no top crust. Take the whites of three eggs for each pie and whip to a stiff froth, and sweeten with three tablespoonfuls of powdered sugar. Flavour with rose-water or vanilla; beat until it will stand alone; then spread it on the pie one-half to one inch thick; set it back into the oven until the meringue is well "set." Eat cold.

My Unforgetable Peach Pie

I recall attending a men's breakfast meeting at a little country church back in the early 1980s, where the Women's Institute had prepared the brunch. There were so many homemade pies to choose from, but I didn't have to make a choice.

While holding a large deep-dish peach pie, my cousin's husband seated next to me asked, "Do you like peaches, Don?" Before I could reply, Roy had sliced the pie in half, sliding one half onto my plate and the other onto his. It was delicious and as expected, quite filling.

You May Also Like

Homemade Pie Recipes

Custom Search

Enjoy a Laugh to Brighten Your Day!

Abbott and Costello

Listen to Bud Abbott and Lou Costello's "Who's On First?" skit from the World War 2 Special Services Division V-Disk.

(5: 54 min.)


Have your say! Leave a friendly comment about Grandma's old fashioned desserts in the box below. (No links or promotion please.)

Like This Page? Please Share It

Visit the Homemade Dessert Recipes Home Page

Old Fashioned Rose Cookbook Icon

Donald Bell is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com. If you make a purchase through a link on this page, I may receive a small commission to help support this site — at no extra cost to you. Thank you.

Don Bell with Old Fashioned Recipes

Please click the Like button above and help me preserve Grandma's old fashioned recipes in their original form.

Need Help?

Puzzled about old time oven temperatures and measurement units? Click the Button below for helpful conversions.

Help Button Icon

Mystery Quiz

Mystery Item

What is this antique item? The Answer is found below.

Recent Articles

  1. Downspout 10 String Wind Harp

    I watched the video on making an Aeolian downspout harp and proceeded to create one: a 3x4-inch, 3 foot long, 10 string, 2 sided wind harp. I thought it

    Read More

  2. My Solo Build It Review & How to Build a Recipe Site

    Read my detailed Solo Build It Review with Q&As and step-by-step instructions on How to Build a Recipe Site.

    Read More

  3. Bake Homemade Pie Pops Today

    Make your own flaky, golden pie pops and surprise your friends and family with a truly yummy dessert treat that's easy to make and fun to serve.

    Read More

  4. Vintage Dessert Cake Recipes

    You will love these old fashioned dessert cake recipes for when you want to serve something that's proven to be delicious and different.

    Read More

  5. Basic Homemade Cake Recipe with 12 Variations

    You'll love this basic homemade cake recipe with simple variations for making up to 12 vintage dessert cakes.

    Read More


Quiz Answer

Grandma's button hooks for  fastening tight buttons on leather boots and gloves.