How to Choose the Best Donut Cutter

By Don Bell / Recipe Archivist and Compiler

The best donut cutter is one that's easy to use, making it one of the handiest kitchen gadgets to have in your cupboard. With the right tool, you will enjoy making perfect-looking donuts the quick and easy way at home. Grandma would have loved having a high-quality cutter, and you will too.

It's not always easy to find a durable dough cutter for donut making since many local brick-and-mortar stores only carry flimsy plastic models that don't slice cleanly. However, knowing what features to look for will help you find a great tool that does the job well and stands up to years of service.

Finding the Perfect Size and Shape

Homemade Donut Dough Ready for the OvenNow You Can Easily Cut Perfect Homemade Donuts
(Source: ©Shaiith79/Depositphotos.com)

A great all-purpose donut cutter should cut a perfect, classic shape to make the best-sized donuts for serving. Look for a model that yields rings that puff up to a good size — not too big, and not too small. As a bonus, this standard sizing is also perfect for making homemade small bagels.

When shopping, look for these design specifications:

  • The Ideal Diameter: A standard outer edge diameter of about 3-1/2 inches with a 1-inch center hole is ideal for everyday baking.
  • Comfortable Handling: The cutter should be designed to fit comfortably in the palm of your hand so it does not feel awkward or make your hand tired when pressing down on thick dough.

Look for Quality Stainless Steel Construction

Well-made, high-quality stainless steel models are generally superior to plastic types. Sharp cutting edges are essential because they slice cleanly through dough without any mess or fuss.

When evaluating the construction, keep these factors in mind:

  • An Open-Top Design: Choose a cutter with an open top. This prevents suction clogs and ensures you won't have to constantly pry the soft dough out of the tool. This allows you to cut a dozen or more donuts effortlessly, just like the pros.
  • Sharpness and Care: A professional cutting edge should be sharp, so take care when using and washing it. Treat it with the same respect you would give a kitchen knife.
  • Easy Maintenance: Stainless steel is not only durable and rust-resistant, but it is also completely dishwasher safe. This makes cleanup incredibly easy and safe to leave in the drying cycle overnight.

What Real Bakers Say to Look For

When reading user reviews for various donut cutters online, highly rated models generally receive praise for the following characteristics:

  • Slicing the dough into perfect, uniform shapes every time.
  • Being the exact right size for both yeast and cake doughnuts.
  • Giving homemade pastries a very neat, professional look.
  • Featuring a sturdy rim or handle that is comfortable to grip and hold.

How to Avoid Common Pitfalls

Perfect Cut DonutsMake Perfectly Cut Homemade Donuts
(Source: ©vulkanov11@gmail.com/Depositphotos.com)

Grandma's Tip

Fry the little "donut holes" and sprinkle them with powdered sugar and cinnamon. Everybody loves to nibble on them!

The most frequent complaint bakers have when using any cutter is that the dough sticks to the metal or plastic surfaces.

However, sticking depends a great deal on how well your dough was made, and it is easily rectified. Simply dip your cutter into a little bit of flour before stamping each donut. The flour acts as a natural barrier and prevents the dough from clinging to the edges.

Just imagine how thrilled your family will be with fresh, homemade donuts that look and taste just like Grandma's. By choosing a durable, sharp, and comfortably sized tool, you'll be frying or baking perfect treats for years to come.

You Might Like These

Grandma McIlmoyles Little Dessert Book

Sign Up now for GRANDMA'S DESSERT CLUB and download your FREE PDF COPY of Grandma McIlmoyle's Little Dessert Book. Also receive my regular Bulletin featuring classic recipes and nostalgia.


Learn More

don-bell-recipe-archivist

Don Bell, Founder & Archivist, Old Fashioned Dessert Recipes. Don has spent over two decades preserving heritage dessert recipes from handwritten family notebooks, recipe scrapbooks, and vintage cookbooks. His collection spans hundreds of authentic, old fashioned recipes presented exactly as originally written.

Google Preferred Source Badge

Like This Page? Please Share It

If you enjoyed reading this page and its old fashioned recipes, please consider sharing it. I choose to spend my time adding more recipes instead of posting on social media, so I rely on readers like you to help spread the word. Use the sharing buttons below!